Medicine Box
By
Medicine Box Staff
Tyler Childers photo (7:5) for Old Money

Introduction

You can ask this song why as many times as you like, and it will hand you the same two words back every time. Old money. By the end you're still sitting there with the question in your mouth, and the song has made sure you understand that nobody is coming to answer it. The grudge in "Old Money" is aimed less at the size of anybody's bank account than at the fact that the people holding it never move, never sweat, never lift a lid, and the very first line says that stillness is the whole secret to how they lasted.

Verse one: cussing up the hill

Start with the line that sets the terms, because everything after it hangs off this one idea.

"Old money don't go walking that's how it got so old"

Money that stays put piles up, and families that stay put get to call themselves old, so what the rich would call patience or legacy the narrator calls sitting on your hands for a few hundred years. From there the verse turns into a roast, and a filthy one. Left to its own devices, old money wouldn't know "whether to shit or go blind or how to lift a lid," which pairs an old saying for total helplessness with the plainest chore you can think of. The richest people in the song can't open a jar.

"Old money planting orchards of little rotten kids"

An orchard is about the slowest work there is, trees you plant for grandchildren, and old money does plant one, but the crop is its own spoiled heirs. Fruit rots when it hangs too long and nobody picks it, and these kids have been hanging on the family tree their whole lives. Set that against the narrator measuring himself as "a thousand fruitful seasons shy" of their status, counting the gap in harvests the way somebody who has actually worked ground would count it.

"Silver spoons of dog shit eakin' out their teeth"

The verb in that line is hard to pin down on the page, but the picture survives it fine. They were born with the silver spoon, everybody knows the phrase, and the song loads the spoon with dog mess and leaves it stuck in their teeth. What they inherited is foul, they're still chewing on it, and they expect you "to do it all and basically for free" while they pick at it.

There's a contradiction sitting right in the middle of all this. The narrator faults them for looking down their noses, then spends the whole verse looking down his own at their bowels and their eyesight. I'll admit that doesn't bother me much, because from the bottom of the hill a cuss word is the only high ground going. You grin.

The "my word" couplet

The narrator puts on a voice here, the rich clucking that they wouldn't pay "that" for any kind of help, all while having no clue how the job gets done. It's a cheap shot and a good one.

The turn: why ain't they no relief

Before the questions start, the verse closes on "a blight among the ash of this American dream," a sick tree standing in a field that already burned. The dream went up in smoke some time ago and the rot is still spreading through what's left. Then the song stops laughing at them and starts talking about you.

"Why ain't they no relief? Why can't you get ahead?"

The pronoun swings around and points at the listener. The bills, the paycheck that never quite stretches, the sense that you're running in place no matter how hard you push. Root hog or die 'til the day he's dead is the old frontier rule that you scratch for your own living or you starve, and the song asks why that rule only ever applies to one side of town. Old money doesn't root. It sits.

And then comes the line that drains the fun out of everything before it: "Why're you up worrying while your youngins are asleep?" The kids are in bed, the house is dark, and a parent is awake doing math that won't come out right. The rotten kids in the orchard had somebody to tend them. These kids have somebody losing sleep so they don't have to. Nobody's grinning now.

Corporations raised like children

The second verse takes the orchard idea and makes it bigger. Old money is now "birthing corporations raising them up right," raising them like people "'neath the ever-watchful eye" of the government. Notice who gets watched over in this song. The corporations have a guardian, and the working family has a parent staring at the ceiling.

Then the song does something brave and strange: it lets the other side talk, and gives them their best material.

"You'd just see prices rising, your milk, your eggs, your cheese"

A grocery list is the most persuasive thing you can wave at a working family, because it's their actual Saturday, and the inflation argument gets every item in it. The narrator's rebuttal is one flat line: it "would not change a thing about the ways of old money." The song's answer to the economics is that the economics are a story told to keep the money right where it's been sitting. A fair-minded fan could hear those grocery lines as the narrator half-believing the warning, scared of it the way anybody living close to the bone gets scared, and that reading holds up. To my ear the flat refusal that follows settles it: the threat is real, and it's being used to keep the wage right where it was.

Time clocks, sheaves, and the river

The last stretch goes back to the first line and finishes the case. They "ain't never punched a time clock" and never wrestled with "bringing in the sheaves," the old hymn's picture of a harvest hauled in by hand. So the orchard comes full circle: old money planted, but somebody else always did the picking.

"They sold you up the river, they sold you overseas"

Here, finally, old money moves. Up the river is the old phrase for being sold off and betrayed, and overseas is where the work went. The only time these people stir from their chairs is to make a sale, and you're what's being sold.

Conclusion

Every "why" in this song gets the same answer, right up until the last one. That final "Why?" hangs there with no "old money" after it, and I hear the silence as the whole argument coming to rest: by now the answer is too plain to need saying, and saying it again would only pretend that naming them changes anything. Put this on driving home off second shift with the check short on the light bill again, and you'll notice the song does the one thing old money never has. It keeps moving, keeps asking, keeps working the question over, and that restless asking is the only thing in the song old money will never get its hands on.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is "Old Money" by Tyler Childers about?

The song is an angry indictment of inherited wealth, aimed at rich families who never work, never move, and expect working people to do everything for next to nothing. It moves from mocking the rich to asking why working families can never get ahead, then widens its target to corporations and a government that won't raise the minimum wage.

What does "Old money planting orchards of little rotten kids" mean?

An orchard takes generations to grow, and the line says the only thing old money cultivates over all that time is spoiled heirs. Rotten fruit is fruit left hanging too long, which fits children raised on inherited wealth without ever having to work.

What does "root, hog, or die" mean in "Old Money"?

Root hog or die is an old saying meaning you scratch out your own living or you starve. In the song, the narrator asks why working people live by that rule their whole lives while old money never has to root for anything at all.

Lyric analysis powered by Scalpel.

Comments

No account needed. We’ll give you a friendly nickname.

Loading comments…