Medicine Box
By
Medicine Box Staff
hemlocke springs photo (7:5) for head, shoulders, knees and ankles

"head, shoulders, knees and ankles" is about catching love while mocking it. The narrator watches a jealous cupid infect a stranger with an urge to kiss calves, sneers at him, and after one glance has him clamped to their own ankles. Love in this song climbs from the floor up, and the scornful spectator ends up shot, seasick, and plotting violence.

Introduction

"Well, now I'm stumbling along with heavy ankles" is the narrator complaining about a man glued to their feet, and it is also the most honest description of falling for someone anywhere in the song. Every love song promises to sweep you off your feet, but this one grabs you by them instead, so you shuffle across the room hauling a suitor like a ball and chain that has opinions. The title already pulled the trick, swapping the nursery rhyme's toes for ankles, which happens to be precisely where a shackle goes. What follows is a farce about a gossip who believes love only happens to fools, right up until it happens to them.

Cupid in the tabloids, viewed from a safe pew

So who is the angel with the cupid's bow? Cupid, obviously, though recast as a "her" with "a rash demeanor" and "a jealousy that only seems to grow," which makes the patron saint of romance sound like a menace on a group chat. The stutter echo on "bo-bo-bo-bow" pokes at the double meaning, since a cupid's bow is both the weapon and the curve of an upper lip, so the thing that shoots you and the thing that kisses you share a name.

"I wonder who's walking around with fertilizer / And amplifying all the tension in her head"

Fertilizer is a gorgeous little joke: jealousy here gets literally gardened, which keeps us on theme when cupid wanders "from the Garden of Eden / To the tenebrous festered corners of your bed." Paradise to a damp mattress in two lines. The song treats love's migration from heaven to your sheets as a demotion.

Then the chorus delivers its medical bulletin. Cupid "pierced a wandering stranger, now he has such a fatal disease," and the disease, announced with the gravity of a plague report, turns out to be kissing people "just below the knees." Then the clincher, delivered like a doctor removing their glasses: "I fear he has a fetish giving calves a squeeze." The fatal disease is infatuation, sure, but infatuation pointed firmly downward, at the parts of the body nobody writes sonnets about.

The narrator watches all this "from somewhere where I know I can't be seen" and pronounces judgment: the man is "a ruffian with a countenance so drawn," and "you couldn't pay me in the flesh to tread the ground he's treading on." Lovely, crisp contempt. Then comes the hiccup: "At least I thought that's what I said." The narrator can't even vouch for their own sneer.

One fleeting look, and the joke turns around

Verse two opens by demolishing the premise of verse one (well, there's an "ugh" in the ad-libs to announce it), because the narrator who was so sure they couldn't be seen manages to catch the man's "poor attention" with "one fleeting look." Invisibility lasted exactly as long as it was funny. The stranger who kissed calves for sport has a new set of calves.

"I found a tumbleweed, he found someone to blame"

That line is the best accounting of a lopsided crush I've heard in a while. The narrator's prize is a tumbleweed, a ball of rolling nothing, while he walks away with a whole person to pin his feelings on. Cupid's arrow made him sick, and now the narrator is the one who has to deal with the symptoms.

The "warning, the past aforementioned" and its kicker, "it's in your name," stay deliberately foggy, and I'll admit whose name the line means resists me. My best guess is that the warning was always printed on the label: a cupid does what cupids do, so honey, what did you expect?

Then the ankles get heavy. "I want to kick him off, but I don't think I can," the narrator says, while the ad-libs lose all decorum ("Get the fuck off, what the hell"). The vocabulary stays absurdly genteel around the panic, with "all the choler and vexation that he rankled," which is how a Regency heroine would describe being tackled at the shins. And the solution floated with impeccable manners is to "chop his little man," with a "chop, chop, chop" chorus of helpers chiming in.

Notice what the narrator can't do, though. They have the rage, the vocabulary, and the knife in mind, and they still can't kick him off. Love has them by the ankles and they keep walking anyway, stumbling but moving, which is a funny thing to do with someone you claim to despise. The contempt was the first symptom.

The arrow finds the narrator, and the money comes out

The second chorus flips the camera. "Lately" becomes "frequently," and the narrator who used to watch cupid from a hiding spot now has cupid's "golden silhouette" lingering "right before my eye," until an arrow strikes their chest and sets their "heart to beat awry." The spectator has been promoted to patient.

Watch the money. A chorus ago you "couldn't pay me in the flesh" to go near this man's ground, and now the narrator has "paid a pretty penny to procure the pirates of Perai" and set sail. The destination is perfect: a ship "that leads me to the tears I cry," a full naval expedition into one's own crying. Grief gets the epic treatment it always believes it deserves.

"If war is what you want, then war will be the book that I will con"

To con is to memorize, as in conning a book, and it's also to steer a ship, which matters two lines after hiring pirates. The narrator is studying war and navigating by it at once, while calling cupid "the villain treating humans like a pawn." Fair complaint. And then, again, "she was gone."

The outro's love letter, with a broken-arms clause

After a "fuck" and a resigned "huh, okay," the tone softens into something almost bridal: "So stay with me forever / Make this dream a heaven-sent." Forever, from the person who wanted to kick someone off their ankles a verse ago. My read is that the narrator is finally talking to the man who's been clinging to them, because the next request is a team activity.

"The more I see, the better / Hell, we can break his arms together"

So what does "break his arms together" mean? Go back to the first line of the song, where cupid is "armed with an arrow." Breaking cupid's arms means disarming him (the pronoun slips from "her" to "his," because enemies get misgendered in wartime), snapping the limbs that draw the bow so nobody gets shot again. The narrator and their ankle-barnacle become co-conspirators against the matchmaker, which is the most romantic thing anyone does in the song. A reasonable fan could hear it the other way, with the narrator recruiting cupid to break the clingy man's arms, and the song leaves that door open; I just think "stay with me forever" is a strange thing to say to the archer you just declared war on.

The final lines about "the glory that you tabled" and "my little rendezvous of age" fold the whole mess into a date. Violence, pirates, and a nice evening out.

Conclusion

The narrator starts the song as a critic in the balcony, sure that love is a disease for drawn-faced ruffians who squeeze calves, and ends it hobbled, heartsick, broke from pirate fees, and asking someone to stay forever. Love in this song never descends from heaven in a beam of light; it creeps up from the floor, grabs the ankles, and gets heavier the more you insist you're fine. The joke the narrator tells about the stranger turns out to be autobiography with a delay. And the happiest ending on offer is two people who couldn't escape each other agreeing to go break cupid's arms, which is about as close to a vow as this song was ever going to get.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is "head, shoulders, knees and ankles" by hemlocke springs about?

It's a comic story about a narrator who mocks a stranger cupid has made lovesick, then becomes his target and gets shot by cupid too. The man clings to the narrator's ankles, the narrator declares war on cupid, and the song ends with a plea to stay forever and break cupid's arms together.

Who is the angel with the cupid's bow, and what is the fatal disease?

The angel is cupid, written as a jealous, rash figure who roams from Eden to people's beds. The "fatal disease" she gives the stranger is infatuation, played for laughs as an obsession with kissing below the knees and "giving calves a squeeze."

What does "break his arms together" mean at the end of the song?

The song opens with cupid "armed with an arrow," so breaking his arms reads best as disarming cupid so he can't shoot anyone again. Paired with "stay with me forever," it turns the narrator and the clingy suitor into partners teaming up against the matchmaker who caused all the trouble.

Lyric analysis powered by Scalpel.

Comments

No account needed. We’ll give you a friendly nickname.

Loading comments…